| 1939-1940 | |||||
| Head Coach Bill Crowell | |||||
| 9-11 (.450) | |||||
| Scores vs. Opponents | Scores vs. Opponents | Individual Scoring | |||
| Union-New Castle | 21-25 | Sandy Lake | 34-23 | Dick Ely | 197 |
| Zelienople | 38-22 | Grove City | 34-23 | Ralph Rhoads | 128 |
| Sandy Lake | 34-14 | West Middlesex | 26-17 | Kenny Nelson | 112 |
| Zelienople | 30-32 | Wilmington | 29-35 | Earl Hanna | 83 |
| Alumni | 29-27 | West Middlesex | 41-46 | Bunk Bartholomew | 24 |
| Sharpsville | 34-31 | Greenville | 21-36 | Blyde Dight | 22 |
| Wilmington | 23-38 | Sharpsville | 21-49 | Elliott Amon | 13 |
| Greenville | 22-40 | Hickory | 30-18 | Larry Strosser | 6 |
| Hickory | 26-50 | Sharon | 22-32 | John DeAngio | 3 |
| Union-New Castle | 39-40 | Grove City | 33-30 | Bob Ely | 1 |