| 1958-1959 | |||||
| Head Coach Tony Stillson | |||||
| 12-12 (.500) | |||||
| Scores vs. Opponents | Scores vs. Opponents | Individual Scoring | |||
| West Middlesex | 47-48 | Cranberry | 51-56 | David M. King | 372 |
| Wilmington | 58-42 | Grove City | 58-53 | John Crill | 272 |
| Grove City | 44-48 | Rocky Grove | 66-61 | Lowell Knowlton | 159 |
| Rocky Grove | 61-50 | Sharpsville | 54-73 | Wendell Zigo | 159 |
| West Middlesex | 29-51 | Hartford | 48-47 | Findley McConnell | 109 |
| Saegertown | 46-50 | Lakeview | 50-54 | Ed Brown | 60 |
| Wilmington | 58-54 | Sharpsville | 42-62 | Tom Crawshaw | 39 |
| Hickory | 57-35 | Cochranton | 41-43 | Ernie Weaver | 26 |
| Lakeview | 47-49 | Hickory | 57-50 | Wayne King | 15 |
| Greenville | 54-51 | Cranberry | 60-44 | Dick Edeburn | 11 |
| Cochranton | 65-43 | Evans City | 42-39 | Dick Sproat | 5 |
| Greenville | 44-52 | Mohawk | 50-52 | Bill Harton | 2 |