| 1959-1960 | |||||
| Head Coach Tony Stillson | |||||
| 16-9 (.640) | |||||
| Scores vs. Opponents | Scores vs. Opponents | Individual Scoring | |||
| Wilmington | 39-38 | Greenville | 47-35 | Dick Edeburn | 304 |
| Butler | 53-44 | Cochranton | 51-53 | John Crill | 255 |
| Grove City | 30-49 | Cranberry | 62-57 | Wendell Zigo | 227 |
| Rocky Grove | 58-49 | Grove City | 63-51 | Findley McConnell | 180 |
| Greenville | 46-41 | Rocky Grove | 63-43 | Wayne King | 174 |
| Sharpsville | 49-61 | Sharpsville | 42-63 | Tom Crawshaw | 78 |
| West Middlesex | 43-55 | Hartford | 58-47 | Ed Brown | 30 |
| Fredonia | 62-34 | Lakeview | 45-43 | Dick Jackal | 16 |
| Union-Rimersburg | 49-42 | West Middlesex | 49-55 | Ernie Weaver | 14 |
| Wilmington | 69-45 | Cochranton | 65-63 | Dick Sproat | 7 |
| Hickory | 46-48 | Hickory | 47-55 | Lee Adams | 5 |
| Lakeview | 43-35 | Cranberry | 62-52 | ||
|
Playoffs |
|||||
| Cochranton (tie-breaker) | 50-55 | ||||